| 
                      
                        
                          |   |  
                          | 1 LP -
                                    SAWT 9528-A - (p) 1968 |  
                          |  |  
                          | 1 CD -
                                  4509-97470-2 - (c) 1995 |  
 | 
                      
                        
                          | CONCERTI A
                                CINQUE, A QUATTRO, A TRE - CIRCA
                                1705-1720 | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | Antonio
                                  VIVALDI (1678-1741) | Concerto
                                in D major for recorder, oboe, violin,
                                bassoon and basso continuo, PV 207
                              (RV 94) | 
 | 10' 18" | A1 |  
                          | 
 | -
                              (Allegro · Largo · Allegro) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | Concerto
                                in D major for recorder, violin and
                                violoncello, PV 198 (RV 92) 
 | 
 | 9' 26" | A2 
 |  
                          | 
 | -
                              (Adagio · (?) · Allegro) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | Concerto in G minor for
                                recorder, oboe, violin, bassoon and
                                basso continuo, PV 403 (RV 105) | 
 | 8' 30" | B1 |  
                          | 
 | -
                              (Allegro · Largo · Allegro) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | Concerto
                                in C major for recorder, oboe, 2 violins
                                and basso continuo, PV 81 (RV 87) | 
 | 7' 17" | B2 |  
                          | 
 | -
                              (Adagio. Allegro · Largo · Allegro assai) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | Concerto
                                in A minor for recorder, 2 violins and
                                basso continuo, PV 77 (RV 108) | 
 | 7' 08" | B3 |  
                          | 
 | -
                              (Allegro · Largo · Allegro) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                      
                      
                        | Frans
                              BRÜGGEN, recorder in f' (copy by
                              Martin Skowroneck, Bremen 1966, of an alto
                              recorder by P. J. Bressan) Jürg SCHAEFTLEIN, oboe (P.
                              Paulhahn, German, c. 1720)
 Otto FLEISCHMANN, bassoon (Vienna
                              18th century)
 Alice HARNONCOURT, violin
                              (Jacobus Stainer, Absam 1658)
 Walter PFEIFFER, violin (Jacobus
                              Stainer, Absam 1677)
 Nikolaus HARNONCOURT, violoncello
                              (Andrea Castagneri, Paris 1744)
 Gustav LEONHARDT, harpsichord
                              (copy of an Italian instrument of c. 1700
                              by Martin Skowroneck, Bremen)
 
 | 
 |  
 
 
                    
                      
                        
                          
                            
 
                              
                                
                                  | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Luogo
                                        e data di registrazione | 
 | Johann Strauss Saal
                                      in Casino Zögernitz, Vienna
                                      (Austria) - 1/4 Marzo 1968 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Registrazione: live
                                        / studio | 
 | studio | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Producer | 
 | Wolf Erichson 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Prima Edizione LP | 
 | Telefunken "Das Alte
                                      Werk" | SAWT 9528-A | 1 LP -
                                      durata 42' 39" | (p) 1968 | ANA 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Edizione CD | 
 | Teldec Classics
                                        "Frans Brüggen Edition" Vol. 8 |
                                        LC 6019 | 4509-97470-2 | 1 CD -
                                        durata 63' 29"  | (c) 1995
                                        | ADD 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Cover 
 | 
 | Cristofano Munari
                                      "Still Life". 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Note | 
 | - 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                              
 
                                  | Concerto in
                                              D major for flute, oboe,
                                              violin, bassoon and basso
                                              continuo (PV 207)Vivaldi’s inexhaustible
                                            richness of invention is
                                            already apparent in the
                                            first concerto on this disc,
                                            which in the outer movements
                                            is almost a violin concerto,
                                            in the middle movement
                                            almost a trio-sonata. The
                                            first movement begins with a
                                            ritornello theme whose
                                            simplicity and
                                            effectiveness, almost in the
                                            character of a popular song,
                                            is itself unusual for
                                            Vivaldi’s concerto
                                            movements. This is followed
                                            by broadly planned solos,
                                            which are interrupted by
                                            terse tuttis, and in which
                                            the virtuosity of the violin
                                            is increased from time to
                                            time. The other instruments
                                            put in a word with short
                                            solos, especially the flute,
                                            which in the first and
                                            second solo-complex is
                                            accompanied by bassoon and
                                            continuo, but in the third
                                            has an enchanting broad
                                            cantilena over violin
                                            arpeggios, while the
                                            bassoon, now also treated as
                                            a soloist, plays broken
                                            chords with the continuo.
                                            The slow movement entrusts
                                            to the flute a well-known
                                            favourite theme of Vivaldi’s
                                            of noble singing quality,
                                            and in a highly original way
                                            combines the violin (in
                                            arpeggios) and bassoon
                                            (without bass or
                                            harpsichord) into a
                                            quasi-continuo group. The
                                            finale begins - again
                                            unusually - with a violin
                                            solo, from which first an
                                            emphatic unison tutti slowly
                                            develops: this then again
                                            becomes a very virtuosic
                                            concerto movement for the
                                            violin before the final
                                            ritornello.
 
 Concerto in D major for
                                              flute, violin and bassoon
                                              or violoncello (PV 198)
 If our first concerto was a
                                            chamber-style violin
                                            concerto, the second work on
                                            this disc is a
                                            concerto-style chamber
                                            sonata for flute and violin
                                            with a bass which is handled
                                            half as a concertante, half
                                            as a continuo. The
                                            three-movement sequence of
                                            Vivaldi’s typical concerto
                                            and the form of the
                                            movements (a sequence of
                                            tuttis and solos in the
                                            quick movements, ternary
                                            song form or binary dance
                                            form in the slow ones) are
                                            compulsorily retained here,
                                            but are differentiated as
                                            chamber music, appropriately
                                            to the small, dynamically
                                            limited, instrumentation.
                                            Thus the first movement has
                                            a “tutti” which, in the
                                            characteristic style of this
                                            genre of works, is relaxed
                                            into concertante dialogues.
                                            The vivacious and capricious
                                            character of the theme of
                                            this ritornello, shooting up
                                            like a rocket, is preserved
                                            throughout this movement, in
                                            which occur ever more
                                            imaginatively modified
                                            ritornellos and solos, in
                                            which flute and violin are
                                            treated idiomatically
                                            throughout (arpeggios for
                                            the violin), and even the
                                            bass frequently intervenes
                                            as a concertante voice and
                                            is not a mere continuo
                                            support. The short, entirely
                                            cantabile Larghetto leads to
                                            a finale which in tone and
                                            technique matches the first
                                            movement, though the
                                            concertante freedom of the
                                            movement and the
                                            independence of the continuo
                                            are pursued more
                                            consistently and more
                                            wittily.
 
 Concerto in G minor for
                                              flute, oboe, violin,
                                              bassoon and basso continuo
                                              (PV 403)
 The G minor concerto acts as
                                            a heightened blend of the
                                            tendencies of the two
                                            previous works: the
                                            supremacy of one single
                                            instrument is broken, and
                                            the governing principle is
                                            of concertante playing
                                            shared between all the
                                            instruments, singly or in
                                            changing groups: only the
                                            three-movement concerto form
                                            and the vestiges of the
                                            block-like exchanges between
                                            tutti and solo still call to
                                            mind the genre whose name
                                            the work bears. Thus the
                                            first movement begins with a
                                            stormy solo for the bassoon,
                                            who is answered by a sighing
                                            figure on the other
                                            instruments over a pedal
                                            point, and the contrast
                                            between these two elements
                                            determines the whole
                                            movement and lends it a
                                            specific character poised
                                            between violence and
                                            pensiveness. As in our first
                                            concerto, the second
                                            movement here is entirely
                                            chamber-music in style: a
                                            lyrical Largo, conceived as
                                            a duet between flute and
                                            bassoon, and reminiscent of
                                            a basso continuo movement
                                            only in the division of
                                            roles (melody on the flute,
                                            running semiquavers on the
                                            bassoon). The finale is not
                                            a concerto movement but a
                                            dance approximating to a
                                            quick 3/8 minuet in type,
                                            though with its concertante
                                            line richly distributed: it
                                            is individual and, for a
                                            Vivaldi finale, quite
                                            unusually serious in its
                                            chromatically sighing melody
                                            and in its striking thematic
                                            reminiscences of the opening
                                            movement.
 
 Concerto in C major for
                                              flute, oboe, 2 violins and
                                              basso continuo (PV 81)
 The C major concerto makes
                                            use of a layout for two
                                            woodwinds and two strings,
                                            while allowing the
                                            instruments to play not only
                                            among themselves but in
                                            groups, and thereby obtains
                                            colourful effects,
                                            especially in the trill
                                            passages of the first
                                            movement. This begins with
                                            an astonishing anticipation
                                            of Haydn’s slow
                                            introductions, in which the
                                            main theme of the Allegro is
                                            foreshadowed: for the rest,
                                            it is entirely attuned to
                                            Vivaldi’s C major style,
                                            with signal-like triad
                                            motives, virtuoso
                                            figurations and fixed tonal
                                            planes. The slow movement is
                                            a flute solo with continuo.
                                            The finale, in form a
                                            concerto movement like the
                                            first, is almost entirely
                                            built on its signal motive
                                            (so that a close relation
                                            between the outer movements
                                            in theme and cast is
                                            produced, unusual in
                                            Vivaldi): in its simplicity
                                            of gesture and the
                                            effectiveness of its key
                                            relationships, as for
                                            example in the turn to E
                                            minor of the third tutti of
                                            an exciting “final dance”,
                                            it is the equal of the
                                            composer’s best solo
                                            concertos.
 
 Concerto in A minor for
                                              flute, 2 violins and basso
                                              continuo (PV 77)
 The A minor concerto clearly
                                            recalls the second concerto
                                            on our record - not only in
                                            its instrumentation and in
                                            the kinship of the latter’s
                                            first movement to its finale
                                            (with nearly identical
                                            principal subjects), but
                                            above all in the
                                            chamber-type differentiation
                                            of the movement with the aid
                                            of concertante techniques.
                                            Almost more strongly than in
                                            the previous case, here also
                                            traditional
                                            concerto-movement form - the
                                            standard concerto
                                            three-movement sequence - is
                                            undermined. On the other
                                            hand however the remains of
                                            the solo concerto are
                                            clearer - especially in that
                                            both violins here move
                                            together practically
                                            throughout, in lyrical
                                            parallel thirds or in broken
                                            chords, and so, as a kind of
                                            continuo layout, contrast
                                            with the flute (which is
                                            treated as a soloist). The
                                            first movement owes its
                                            attractiveness to the
                                            tension between the
                                            “Bachian” anapaest subject
                                            (always treated concertante)
                                            which governs the whole
                                            movement, and a broad
                                            song-like recurrent phrase,
                                            which gives it an intimate
                                            charm. The centre of the
                                            work, however, is the A
                                            minor Largo, a solemn,
                                            almost saraband-like, melody
                                            of wide range for the flute,
                                            which is bathed in an
                                            enchantingly diffused light
                                            from the gentle broken
                                            chords of the violin, in
                                            flowing quaver motion, and
                                            the plodding bass in
                                            crotchets. The finale, a
                                            concise, rhythmically highly
                                            energetic gigue, again
                                            conspicuously and clearly
                                            refers back to the thematic
                                            material of the first
                                            movement, whose dance-rhythm
                                            character and free
                                            dance-movement form,
                                            scarcely still concertante,
 is changed for the vital
                                            gaiety of a real farewell
                                            finale.
 
 Ludwig
                                                FinscherVivaldi’s
                                            solo concertos clearly
                                            concentrate on one type of
                                            form, developing their
                                            individuality from the
                                            tension between typical
                                            form and extensive typical
                                            inflections on the one hand,
                                            and, on the other, the
                                            specific tone-colour of the
                                            solo instruments and
                                            instrumental combinations.
                                            Equally confusingly
                                            colourful and varied in
                                            form, inflections and
                                            instrumental combinations is
                                            the group of concerti
                                            for solo instruments with
                                            continuo, i.e. without
                                            orchestra, which occupy a
                                            historically original and
                                            aesthetically attractive
                                            half-way position between
                                            the chamber sonata and the
                                            solo concerto. Scarcely any
                                            composer in the first half
                                            of the 18th century used
                                            this type of
                                            “concerto without orchestra”
                                            as often and as
                                            imaginatively as did
                                            Vivaldi, and no other, with
                                            the exception of Telemann,
                                            had with such
                                            works a comparable success -
                                            quite apart from his
                                            personal sphere of influence
                                            - although these works
                                            remained unpublished during
                                            Vivaldi’s lifetime.(translated
                                                by Lionel Salter)
 
 Not only in the solo setting
                                            of these pieces do they
                                            resemble chamber-music but,
                                            even more, in their
                                            inclination to
                                            differentiation of the
                                            movement structure, to ever
                                            new and surprising
                                            deviations from traditional
                                            formal schemes or to their
                                            imaginative new realisation;
                                            like
                                            chamber-music too,
                                            especially in slow
                                            movements, are the turns of
                                            phrase, which are far
                                            removed from the
                                            strong-gestured, fiery and
                                            extravert temperament of the
                                            quick concerto-movements as
                                            well as from the hardly less
                                            extravert pathos of many
                                            concerto slow movements.
                                            More typical of the
                                            concerto, on the other hand,
                                            and fully justifying the
                                            title of concerto for these
                                            works, are the pointed,
                                            energyladen unison themes of
                                            the quick movements, in
                                            which the solo ensemble
                                            imitates, as it were, the
                                            sound of the traditional
                                            string orchestra; typical of
                                            the concerto, above all, is
                                            the solo prominence of
                                            individual instruments above
                                            the ensemble of
                                            chamber-music voices,
                                            often with noticeably
                                            virtuoso demands on
                                            technique, such as would
                                            have been foreign to actual
                                            late-Baroque chamber-music;
                                            and finally,
                                            typical of the concerto is
                                            the manner in which the
                                            concerto-like contrasts of
                                            blocks of tutti and soli are
                                            broken up in the course of
                                            the
                                            movements - not by thematic
                                            writing and polyphonic
                                            combination of voices, as
                                            befitted chamber-music
                                            (mostly in the realm of the
                                            triosonata), but by short
                                            solo flourishes, motifs and
                                            thematic fragments, which
                                            bring various instruments
                                            together either singly or in
                                            changing groupings, almost
                                            in dialogue,
                                            “conversational”, and
                                            thereby anticipating the
                                            central idea of classical
                                            chamber-music in respect of
                                            the
                                            principle of concerto
                                            playing, even if as yet
                                            without the principle of
                                            thematic construction.
 These concerti contributed
                                            to the dilution of movement
                                            construction in Baroque
                                            chamber-music, to its
                                            replacement by concerto-like
                                            elements, to the spread of
                                            the concertante
                                            dialogue-principle into the
                                            sphere of chamber-music, as
                                            did, a little later, the
                                            concertini of Sammartini and
                                            his circle, who prepared the
                                            way direct to the string
                                            quartet. But independently
                                            of their historical
                                            importance, Vivaldi’s solo,
                                            chamber-music-like concerti
                                            belong - thanks purely to
                                            their intermediate position
                                            between the only recently
                                            established and the already
                                            changing forms of early
                                            18th-century Italian
                                            instrumental music - to the
                                            most attractive and original
                                            works of this by no means
                                            unoriginal composer.
 
 Ludwig
                                                Finscher
 It seldom happens that a
                                            recording of baroque music
                                            gives us pleasure, although
                                            originally most of that
                                            music was intended to
                                            entertain the musicians as
                                            well as the audience. Being
                                            so far removed in time added
                                            to totally different playing
                                            circumstances - microphones
                                            were not used very much in
                                            the 17th and 18th centuries
                                            - we are then totally and
                                            seriously occupied in trying
                                            to the best of our abilities
                                            to produce a technically and
                                            spiritually perfect picture.
 Recording, however, the
                                            present Concerti, I must
                                            admit that our attitude
                                            turned into a very gay,
                                            sometimes even boyish mood.
                                            The
                                            reason for this was, I
                                            suppose, that we realized
                                            that, although the music had
                                            been written around 1720, we
                                            were actually playing what
                                            sounded like neo-baroque, as
                                            Strawinsky or Milhaud could
                                            have composed. Baroque music
                                            as an arrangement of baroque
                                            music. This
                                            double mirror effect shocked
                                            and enlighted us performers.
                                            The expert might even call
                                            these Concerti bad
                                            compositions of an
                                            untalented
                                            beginner (but Vivaldi wrote
                                            a pile of masterworks in the
                                            same years and earlier),
                                            full of boring themes,
                                            consecutive octaves and
                                            fifths by
                                            the dozen, feeble harmonies
                                            and instrumental errors. How
                                            often during the recording
                                            we almost hysterically got
                                            caught in a giggle when
                                            the dawn of another endless
                                            sequence rose or an
                                            instrumental part proved to
                                            be either out of compass or
                                            unplayable other than with
                                            a technique of much later
                                            date.
 At times Vivaldi was more an
                                            inventor than a composer; he
                                            then left the aestethic
                                            rules behind and played with
                                            derided new, unusual
                                            forms and instrumental
                                            combinations. It has been
                                            this avant-gardism also
                                            which probably inspired
                                            Bach, and, after all, still
                                            inspires musicians and
                                            listeners today.
 
 Frans
                                                Brüggen
 |  
                                  |   |  
                                  | 
 |  
 |