|
Philips
- 1 LP - 9500 409 - (p) 1978
|
|
Philips
Duo - 2 CDs - 446 163-2 - (c) 1995 |
|
Franz Schubert
(1797-1828) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
String
Quartet No. 15 in G major, Op. 161
(D 887) |
|
55' 03" |
|
-
Allegro molto moderato
|
22' 50" |
|
|
-
Andante un poco moto
|
13' 33" |
|
|
-
Scherzo (Allegro
vivace) |
7' 21" |
|
|
-
Allegro assai
|
11' 19" |
|
|
|
|
|
|
QUARTETTO ITALIANO
- Paolo Borciani, Elisa Pegreffi, violino
- Piero Farulli,
viola
- Franco Rossi, violoncello
|
|
|
|
|
|
Luogo e data
di registrazione |
|
Musica
Théâtre
Salle
de Musique, La
Chaux-de-Fonds
(Svizzera)
- 17-23
luglio 1977 |
|
|
Registrazione: live
/ studio |
|
studio |
|
|
Producer / Engineer |
|
Vittorio
Negri | Willem
van Leewen
|
|
|
Prima Edizione LP |
|
Philips | 9500
409
| 1
LP | (p) 1978
|
|
|
Prima Edizione CD |
|
Philips Duo | 446
163-2 | 2 CDs - 75'
41"
- 66' 24" - (2°, 1-4) | (c)
1995 | ADD
|
|
|
Note |
|
-
|
|
|
|
|
As well as
the works of Beethoven -
and this coincidence of
time and quality was
responsible for a deal
of the neglect suffered
by the younger composer
- the early decades of
the nineteenth century
also produced the string
quartets of Schubert,
which were to become
influential models for
the remainder of the
century, particularly
for the quartes of Dvořák
and Reger, but also
for the works of
Bruckner, Wolf, and
Mahler. The G major
Quartet Op. 161,
Schubert's last, most
comprehensive, and,
in the opinion of
many scholars, best
work in this form
was written in the
space of a few days,
between June 20 and
30, 1826.
From
Schubert's
correspondence we
know that it had a
private
performance in the
home of his friend
Vincenz Lachner in
the spring of
1827, in which
Schubert himself
took part. On March 26,
1826 the first
movement of the
quartet was
given at the
only public
concert under
Schubert's own direction,
in the concert
hall "Zum
Roten Igel" of
the Vienna
Musikverein,
the performers
were members
of the famous
Schuppanzingh
Quartet, with
the violinist
Joseph Bohm
substituting
for their
leader, who
was
III.
The first
public
performance of
the whole
work, by the
Hellmesberger
Quartet of
Vienna, was
not until December
8, 1850, the
score, which
Schubert had
tried in vain
in February
1828 no have
printed by the
house of
Schott in
Mainz, was
finally put
out by
Diabelli in
Vienna in
1851.
Since
then G major
Quartet has
for long - in
many cases,
right up to
the present
day - been
overshadowed
in terms of
performance
and
appreciation
by the two
popular
Quartets in A
minor, D. 804
and D minor
("Death
and the
Maiden"), D.
810. There are
two main
reasons for
this; it has
not the
slightest
apparent
connexion with
the two
earlier works;
and its
lenght,
coupled with
the technical
demands it
makes on the
players, may
well have
scared oft
many an
ensemble. In
addition,
critics have
complained of
the work's
"orchestral"
nature,
outwardly
indicated by
numerous
tremolos
without
recognising
the altogether
different
nature of
their function
in the
structure of
the work.
In
terms of form,
tone colour,
and harmony
this G major
Quartet marks
a tremendous
step forward,
beyond
even the
advances made
in the D minor
Quartet;
indeed, the
motto-like
thematic
statement at
the beginning
of the first
movement, on
an otherwise
unconnected
major and
minor chord -
repeated in
the C major
String
Quartet, Op.
163, of 1828 -
has influenced
composers
right up to
Mahler, in his
Sixth
Symphony. Its
emphasis on
variety of
tone colour
and contrasts
of tonality
have had a
strong
influence on
the
development of
harmonic
thinking is
the nineteenth
century,
setting
against
Beethoven's
style of
closely linked
development am
almost
"collage"
-like effect.
The
first movement
of the G major
Quartet (Allegro
molto
moderato),
adheres, in
its broad
lines, to the
sonata
principle -
but of
greeater
interest are
the deviations
from it, for
example what
appears to be
the
disproportionately
lenghtly
treatment of
the secondary
theme, which -
and this is
typically
Schubertian -
with its
changing tone
colours in the
harmony
ezhibits that
calm,
selfcontained
quality that
is so far
removed from
Beethoven's
driving and
striving. The
two-part first
subject,
however,
unfolding itself
against a
background of
the tremolos
already
mentioned,
fits more
obviously into
orthodox
sonata form;
but Schubert,
in the
comprehensive
development
section,
unleashes
harmonic
rather than
structural
forces; and
the
recapitulation,
which begins
with the
continuation
of the opening
motto theme,
is so greatly
changed,
varied, and
developed,
that its
summing-up
function
becomes
unimportant in
comparison
with the
impression it
gives of
striving for
more and still
more harmonic
variety and
increased
excitement in
the individual
parts.
In
spite of the
song-like,
rather
straighforward
setting of the
Andante
un poco moto,
the rhythmic
and harmonic
energy of the
first movement
is still
evident: a
three-bar
bridge passage
juxtaposes
rather than
links it with
a heroic middle
section which
harks back to
the dotted
rhythms and
dynamic
eruptions of
the first
movement, but
these heroices
never take on
the defiant,
"Per aspera ad
astra" bravura
of Beethoven,
which was
alien to
Schubert's
almost modern
style.
The
scherzo, Allegro
vivace,
like the slow
movement set
in the mirror,
may be
compared with
that of the
"Great" C
major Symphony
of 1828, and
its influence
can be felt in
the scherzos
of many
Bruckner
symphonies.
Here, as in
many of the
late quartets
of Haydn, with
whom Schubert
has a closer
affinity than
with
Beethoven, the
theme is nothing,
the treatment
everything. It
is balanced by
a gentle trio
in Landler
form, almost a
piece of genre
writing.
The
finale, Allegro
assai, has
been described
by the
Schubert
scholar Walter
Riezler as one
of "the most
inspired, the
most claring,
and the most
perfect
movements"
that Schubert
ever wrote. In
rondo form,
loaded with
development
material and
in a restless
6/8 rhythm, it
has a certain
relationship
with the
finale of the
D minor
Quartet, but
closer
analysis
reveals the
inner variety
and the
structural,
tonal, and
melodic
richness of
the movement
which, despite
all its
apparently
uncestrained
fantasy,
despite all
the
persipheral
detail, is
tremendously
compact. The
harmonie
ambivalence,
again
expressed here
by the
contrast of
major and
minor, owes a
particular
charm to the
chromatic
writing for
the middle
voices and the
rapid and
continuous
permutations
of basic
tonality; we
have here,
then, a vigour
and an energy
which are
steployed not
only in melody
and rhythm,
but which
contain
contradictory
harmonic
elements
phase
shifting, and
tonal and
structural
principles
which were not
to be
exploined
fully until
the twentieth
century.
Wulf
Konold
|
|
|